
Sometimes I feel like saying "another month, another new photo editor for the iPad." Yes, it's time to take a look at yet another photo editing App for iPad. However, this time things are a little different. At this point if you're a photographer and you have an iPad you've probably dabbled with putting your own photos on your iPad to either display to clients/friends or to review. You can get images onto your iPad directly from your camera using the Apple Camera Connection Kit, the MIC CF Card Reader or even wirelessly using an Eye-Fi card. Once those images are there, you'll probably want to start doing some initial image manipulations. There's certainly no shortage of good capable editors on the App Store. So what possibly could Nik Software bring to the table that we haven't seen before? At this point we expect to be able to Crop, Rotate, do Tonal Adjustments, Apply Frames, Save and Share our edited images. Of course Nik's Snapseed does all of these things and more. What's different is the User Interface (UI). The Snapseed UI shows that companies can still innovate beyond the obvious. It's this fresh take on a NEW image editing UI that makes this App down right addictive.
How is it different?

First off let's start with the fact that it's clean and gets out of your way. There's no tool panel. After you open the image you want to edit you tap on a category of adjustments that you wish to make. At that point you then just tap on the image to bring up a selection of different adjustments you can make. You drag up and down to make your choice and then drag left or right to make the actual adjustment. While this is cool, what Nik brings to the iPad is what they brought to the desktop with their Award Winning Plug-ins for Photoshop, Lightroom, etc. They allow you to affect areas of the image WITHOUT having to make selections. Using their Control Points you just tap to add a Control Point on an area of an image and then use a pinch to adjust the size/radius of the area to be adjusted. Your image is automatically masked behind the scenes. Then you just drag left or right to make the adjustment you want or to apply the filter you want. There is an instant Before/After button that you tap and hold to see the before version and release to see the after version. Of course there are also Undos and Redos and if you leave the App it will remember where you left off. I should point out that Snapseed also has the ever important White Balance adjustment that so many other Apps miss.
Sharing and Room For Improvement

There isn't really much if anything missing from this App and that's why I'm giving it one of my highest ratings. However, when it comes to sharing your choices are Email, Print, Flickr and Facebook. The one that's missing is Twitter. It's not the end of the world because I can save the image and then open it up in my Twitter App of choice and Tweet it. However, it would be nice to have it built-in. The other more major omission is online sharing through Dropbox.com. At this point I really don't want to see any more new Apps that don't integrate with Dropbox.com. Since iOS lacks a built-in user accessible file structure I've come to rely on Dropbox to get files back and forth between Apps and my own devices as well as easily sharing them with friends and colleagues without having to resort to email. Other than the limited sharing features Snapseed is a solid app at a very attractive price. It makes the other Pro level apps in this category seem expensive.


Thanks for the test, downloaded it 2 minutes ago
Does this work with RAW images?
None of the iPad photo editors that I’ve seen to date actually work on the RAW files themselves. Snapseed along with all the others actually does edit the JPG preview embedded in the RAW file (provided that your camera’s RAW format produces a compatible one).
Photogene is able to edit the actual Raw files, have not seen any other programs able to do it other than that one.
I guess that it depends on how you define “editing”? You are correct in that Photogene will open a RAW file for editing. However, once the editing is done your only option is to save as a JPG. In other words this is not really a “RAW” editing workflow where you’re making adjustments that are to the metadata of the RAW file and therefore non-destructive. Again, I’m not saying you’re incorrect and Photogene is a great app, but it really depends on how you define “RAW editing”?
Try Filterstorm Pro. It works with RAW, whether it actually edits the RAW or not as Terry states makes no difference. The fact is you can at least open your RAW photos with Filterstorm and manipulate them. Your Raw photos are useless with snapsead which by definition puts snapsead in a NON pro level category contrary to what Terry says. Snapsead is something you get for your 10 year old daughter to goof off with.
I beg to differ. If you’re going to call something RAW editing then it has to be “RAW Editing” Not merely opening a JPG Preview from a RAW file (which not all RAW files even produce). I’m glad that you’re happy being able to open an edit a JPG “Preview” from your RAW file as most of the editors on the iPad do. It’s not a professional solution, nor is it non-destructive. You’re basically doing an 8Bit JPG work around and that is NOT RAW editing. Snapseed doesn’t offer RAW editing, but technically neither do any of the others. If you’re getting a “bigger” JPG preview file from the other apps and you’re happy with that then so be it. But please don’t call it RAW editing, because it’s NOT.
When you can make adjustments that are non-destructive and will be seen by other RAW editors then you’re doing RAW editing.
Oh and by the way 1.1 was just released and “supports RAW” files. Again I don’t consider this to be “RAW editing”, but at least it puts in on par with the other Apps in this category.
@DT, according to the first listed review in iTunes (just before posting this note) the answer is that today, RAW images are not supported — must be JPEGs or TIFFs.
It’s garbage for raw shooters. So when the reviewer says not much missing from this app, he is mistaken. It will load the jpg from the raw but it’s about the size of a postage stamp. Nik’s response to me was to convert to .jpg on m PC then upload it back to the iPad. Really? If I upload to my PC why wouldn’t I just use LR3 or PS CS5? This is more of a kids program for goofing ff with.
So let me get this straight: You’re saying that editing an 8bit JPG preview from a RAW file is “professional” ?
There isn’t a “RAW” editor for the iPad. Let’s be clear on that.
Thanks for help Terry!
I see what you’re saying about RAW editing Terry, but I feel there’s a very important discinction that you’re glossing over.
Most apps do just open the jpg preview image that cameras embed within the RAW file. With my D90 it’s easy to tell because the jpg preview is quite small, only a few hundred pixels across. When I try to open a RAW file in, for instance, Photoshop Express what I get is this tiny jpg image instead.
In this case you are absolutely correct, this is NOT true RAW editing, and claiming that these apps can open RAW files is highly misleading.
On the other hand, Photogene (and a few others) will actually open the RAW file. What it does then is immediately convert it to a jpg for editing, and if you’re on an iPad 1, as I am, it scales it down a bit (though I suspect that the iPad does the converting when it first imports the RAW, and this is what you’re seeing in the Photos app). Again this is easy to tell because what I get is a beautiful image several thousands of pixels across. From my point of view, this is acceptable because you get an image to edit that is very high quality, even if you end up with a jpg at the end.
In this case, you are not doing true RAW editing, but it is not the same thing as only editing the embeded jpg preview. For all intents and purposes (especially on an iPad 2) you CAN open RAW files, you just can’t export them as anything bit jpg.
There are no real RAW editors on the iPad, sure, but while some editors will only open the tiny jpg preview, there are some that will let you edit a full resolution (or nearly so on iPad 1) version of the file, giving you a far superior result. That distinction is important and should be noted.
Pingback: Snapseed Takes Apple’s Pick as “iPad App of the Year” | Apps Affair